THE HOUSE THAT NEVER WAS

£3 million dream house that’s just that – a dream!
by Phil Green

If you’ve got £3 million to spend on a property you might well be attracted by this detached period house oozing faded elegance from every brick.

Grand mansion allegedly in Edgbaston

It’s advertised for sale by Birmingham estate agents Circle Sales & Lettings in their New Street premises in the heart of the city centre, and on websites like Rightmove, and until recently, Zoopla and Prime Location.

window of Circle Sales & lettings, New Street, Birmingham

The 8 bedroom detached house is described as being in Edgbaston, and offers around  £2,975,000 are invited. Unfortunately, this particular dream house is just that – dreamed up! It does not exist – at least not in that form, or in Birmingham. The exterior photograph is of a house in Cheshire over 70 miles away which featured in the BBC series, ‘The Planners’.

mansion in Cheshire taken from BBC website

The rather over-the-top dining room is actually in Audley House in London, 120 miles away – one of Mayfair’s luxury mansions.

Audley House, ,Mayfair, London

Somerset Road house description

And apart from the first couple of lines, the ‘Property description’ in the online listing is taken word for word from the description of a Grade II Listed villa in Cheltenham, 50 miles away.

description of a house in Cheltenham

But most impressive of all is the garden, which it turns out has been lifted from a site called laurries.blogspot – and is over 3,000 miles away in north central Connecticut, USA!

garden in Connecticut

So, fantastic as it may seem, the Edgbaston dream house is just cobbled together – nothing but an elaborate concoction by Circle Sales. Also offered for sale by the company is an old Birmingham church – a snip at £3,000,000. The church is real, but whether it’s really for sale – God only knows!

Trinity Church, Digbeth, Birmingham

The director of Circle Sales, Ishfaq Ali Hussain, has over 20 active companies at present and his estate agency was preceded by another of his businesses called Clinic Republic which opened to a great fanfare in the Birmingham Mail and offered everything from Eyelash Transplants and Teeth Whitening to Scalp Pigmentation and Vaser Lipo.

image015

It went belly up after less than 2 months – leaving staff and suppliers out of pocket according to Facebook. (Court Judgments against the companies behind Clinic Republic are already in excess of £50,000.) But from the ashes rose Circle Sales offering a wide range of properties from small terraced houses to high-end apartments in the Rotunda and the Mailbox, plus a sprinkling of commercial premises – and the church! Unfortunately, it looks like the Circle Sales offerings could be just cosmetic too, consisting largely of properties taken from other agents’ listings, or made-up, or personally owned by Mr Hussain or one of his companies. He has already had to remove a listing of a house which he himself once owned, and which was repossessed and remarketed in 2013 [below]. It had been trashed.

Andrew Grant listing of house

The current owners were shocked to discover last month that their house was being advertised for sale on Circle Sales [below] – and with a photograph lifted from last year’s listing by the other agent, but now the price was double! The interior pictures were even older, taken before the house was trashed.

house listed on Circle Sales

It may well be that the only genuine listings at Circle Sales are of properties Mr Hussain is associated with. But even more serious, it is a legal requirement for estate agents to be registered with an ombudsman scheme that handles complaints – and Circle Sales is not, which means that if you part with money and things go wrong,  you would have no redress. So the message seems clear – give Circle Sales & Lettings a wide birth and look for your dream house elsewhere.

Circle Sales & Lettings, New Street, Birmingham

If you have personal experience of Mr Ishfaq Ali Hussain, or any information about Circles Sales, Clinic Republic or any other of his numerous companies, that you would like to share, then you can leave a comment by using the link at the top. If you would prefer to send a private message in confidence then please use the form below. Thanks.

Dream On

by Phil Green

Following on from Circles Sales’ listing of the fake ‘Grand Mansion’ in Somerset Road (concocted from images from Cheshire, London, Cheltenham and Connecticut), another dream home was rumbled – this time a £1.5million house allegedly in Bracebridge Road, Sutton Coldfield:

Bracebridge Road

This particular property is actually in Foxcombe Road, south of Oxford, and advertised for sale by Savills estate agents:

Foxcombe Road

Circles Sales’ lengthy online description of the property was lifted virtually word for word from a Quantills listing of an actual house in Bracebridge Road:

Quantrills blurb

The original states:

“The Grange is a Arts and Crafts Grade II Listed family home, built in 1906 by Isaac Langley, a renowned Edwardian builder, and designed by Haywood Farmer…”

…amended by Circle sales to read:

“The Cloves is a Arts and Crafts Grade II Listed family home, built in 1906 by Isaac Langley, a renowned Edwardian builder, and designed by Haywood Farmer.”

In June the agents Savills took exception to their photograph being plagiarised:

SAVILLS CALLS IN LAWYERS OVER LOOKALIKE HOUSE LISTING

Circles Sales response was to replace the stolen picture with another one, equally ‘fake’:

Bracebridge Road in window

This one features a house in Hartopp Road, Sutton Coldfield marketed by Hunters:

Hartopp Road - Hunters

The garden pictures used by Circle have been taken from the websites of 2 garden contractors:

Bracebridge Road 1st garden


Bracebridge Road 2nd garden

Other properties in Circle Sales’ New Street window include this one in Lordswood Road, B17, marked as ‘Sold’:

Lordswood Road in window

But this particular picture is actually of a house in Westfield Road, B15, taken from the website of Simon Michael Homes:

Simon Michael 2

This freehold detached 6 bed house in Shirley, B90, also marked as ‘Sold’…

Shirley

…is actually an office building in Hall Green, B28, offered to let on Office Genie.

Hall Green office on OfficeGenie

This Victorian 4 bed semi-detached house which Circle Sales describes as being in Livingstone Road, Kings Heath, B14…

Livingstone Road in window

…is actually in Barron Road, Northfield, B31:

Barron Road Rice Estates

And the interiors on Circle’s fake listing have been lifted from this old Thornley Groves webpage featuring a house in Broomfield Lane, Hale near Manchester!

Broomfield Lane interiors

This bog standard semi in Stechford Lane, Birmingham B8 with a price tag of £200,000 and an implausible half acre of land attached…

Stechford Lane in window

…would actually set you back nearly £500,000 as it’s in Bushey near Watford:

Pickets Close

As for the attached half acre of land shown on Circle Sales’ display, that is actually a building plot north of Perth in Scotland!

Land for sale Pitnacree

Curiously, this house advertised by Circle Sales as being in Stoney Lane, Yardley actually is in Stoney Lane…

Stoney Lane in window

…although Circle have taken the picture from a Prime Estates listing where the price tag is £60,000 more:

Stoney Lane Prime Estates

However, the featured kitchen and bathroom clearly aren’t in Yardley as they come from two American websites:

kitchen pic


bathroom pic

Finally, you might well think this large Victorian semi in Vivian Road, Harborne has a whiff of sea air about it.

Vivian Road Harborne

That’s because it’s by the coast in Falmouth, Cornwall!

7 bed house Falmouth

But you would have to walk a long way to make a cup of tea because the kitchen is in Brighton…

Southdown Road Brighton

…and even further if you want to drink it outside because the garden is somewhere in the USA!

wdeck.com

So much for Circles Sales & Lettings’ New Street window of dreams. Their suspect listings online on Zoopla, Prime Location, Rightmove etc are another story… But the moral is the same: give this alleged estate agency a wide berth!

Circles Sales window July 2014

EXTENSIONS GALORE

by Phil Green

The man behind Circle Sales, Ishfaq Ali Hussain, is a wannabe property developer and no stranger to controversy. And while his houses, at least, are never lacking in the bedroom department, he just can’t resist erecting huge extensions.

In 2009 the now chairman of Birmingham City Council’s Planning Committee threatened to drive a bulldozer to demolish an unauthorised extension on a property in Stechford owned by one of Mr Hussain’s companies, Intercity Homes, and which he was converting into 12 flats when he only had planning permission for 10. All 12 are now being advertised by Circle Sales. (Shome mishtake, shurely? Ed)

DEVELOPER ORDERED TO DEMOLISH UNAUTHORISED EXTENSION

Mr Hussain's disputed extension of 306 Station Road in 2010

Mr Hussain’s controversial extension of 306 Station Road in 2010

The following year he was in the process of converting his 10 bedroomed house in Russell Road in the Moseley Conservation Area into an HMO (House in Multiple Occupation) without permission, when he was accused by the Planning Department of attempting to build the city’s longest extension “by stealth” after he erected an 80ft long outbuilding in the garden and then applied to connect it to the house (which is also now listed on Circle Sales.)

CITY PLANNERS BLOCK STEALTH EXTENSION

Mr Hussain's disputed 'extension' at 40 Russell Road in 2010

Mr Hussain’s disputed ‘extension’ at 40 Russell Road in 2010

His application was thrown out and he appealed. An independent planning inspector upheld the decision, but in a clear criticism of the council’s earlier approval of the outbuilding he described it as “in no way comparable to the period villa in style, scale or proportion. It looks out of place, excessive and intrusive in this setting.”

40 Russell Road in 2007

40 Russell Road in 2007

Russell Road in 2011 showing Mr Hussain's massive 'extension'

40 Russell Road in 2011 showing Mr Hussain’s massive ‘extension’

But it wasn’t just an extension that Mr Hussain was attempting to build ‘by stealth’ – which he claimed was to house a gym and cinema to keep his many children amused. In fact he had set his sights much higher and had hopes of building a 41 bed care home on the site as this 2009 document from his company, Intercity Homes, shows.

 nursing home plan for 40 Russell Road

The nursing home Mr Hussain was hoping to build in his back garden.

Back at Intercity Homes’ other big project at the time, Mr Hussain’s propensity to avoiding paying bills was dramatically highlighted in 2012 when an exasperated contractor dumped concrete on the Station Road site because he hadn’t been paid. Mr Hussain called the police.

BUILDER STAGES JCB PROTEST BY DUMPING CONCRETE OUTSIDE STECHFORD HOME

The police attempt to calm Mr Hussain down

The police attempt to calm Mr Hussain

The big extension on another of his houses was marginally less controversial (the council approved it retrospectively).

house before trashing

But having fitted a very modern kitchen, Mr Hussain ripped it all out when the house was about to be repossessed by the mortgage company!

trashed house

Do you have a story about Ishfaq Ali Hussain that you would like to share? Then feel free to write a comment using the link at the top. Otherwise, if you prefer, you can send me a private message by filling in the form below.